The The Relativeness of Risks and Threats to Implementation of the (Military) Personnel Policy of Ukraine and the State of Israel Citizens in Terms of (Military) Training

Keywords: Ukraine-Israel, risk analysis, military conflict, military personnel policy, human capital, international cooperation, social security principles, general military training

Abstract

Purpose: is to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the current regulatory and legal framework governing military training of Ukrainian citizens, as well as to identify key challenges, risks, and threats that hinder the implementation of an effective personnel policy in the military sphere in general, and the development of an efficient system of military training for Ukrainian citizens in particular. Based on the results of the analysis, the study seeks to outline ways to resolve the identified issues and to provide scientifically grounded recommendations for the development of an effective and resilient system of military training for Ukrainian citizens.

Method: abstraction, comparison and quantitative-qualitative analysis, synthesis.

Findings: The results of the study conducted contribute to a deeper scientific understanding of approaches to the development and implementation of military personnel policy. They enable stakeholders to increase their awareness of the research subject, identify existing problems and critical issues, reveal weaknesses in the current regulatory framework, and highlight capability gaps in relevant areas. The findings can be used to enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of managerial influence exerted by governing entities on the functioning of the object and subject under investigation in this article.

Theoretical implications: The theoretical value of this study lies in the comparative analysis of military personnel policy in Ukraine and Israel, which makes it possible to identify their common features and differences, as well as to highlight the risks associated with their implementation. By taking into account socio-cultural factors and the current security realities, the research complements existing theories of military training, contributes to a reassessment of the security environment, and brings decision-making processes in the field of human capital development closer to scientifically grounded methods.

Practical implications: lies in the potential application of its findings for developing practical recommendations aimed at enhancing the effectiveness of the military training system for Ukrainian citizens. This may be achieved, in particular, through the adaptation of successful practices from the State of Israel, taking into account the national context and the specific needs of the security and defense sector. The study's results may serve as a scientifically grounded foundation for shaping state policy in the field of military training, aimed at strengthening the country's defense capabilities.

Type of article: theoretical.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Pro vnesennja zmin do Konstytuciji Ukrajiny (shhodo strateghichnogho kursu derzhavy na nabuttja povnopravnogho chlenstva Ukrajiny v Jevropejsjkomu Sojuzi ta v Orghanizaciji Pivnichnoatlantychnogho doghovoru) : Zakon Ukrajiny vid 07.02.2019 № 2680-VIII. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2680-19#Text (data zvernennja 06.10.2024).

Pro zatverdzhennja Porjadku orghanizaciji ta zdijsnennja oboronnogho planuvannja v Ministerstvi oborony Ukrajiny, Zbrojnykh Sylakh Ukrajiny ta inshykh skladovykh syl oborony : Nakaz M-va oborony Ukrajiny vid 22.12.2020 №484. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0196-21#Text (data zvernennja 08.09.2024).

Pro zatverdzhennja planu priorytetnykh dij Urjadu na 2023 rik. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/rada/show/221-2023-r#n13 (data zvernennja 08.09.2024).

Pro zatverdzhennja Koncepciji vijsjkovoji kadrovoji polityky v systemi Ministerstva oborony Ukrajiny na period do 2028 roku: Nakaz M-va oborony Ukrajiny vid 27.10.2023 № 637. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/rada/show/v0637322-23#Text (data zvernennja 06.10.2024).

Ukaz Prezydenta Ukrajiny № 36/2022 – Oficijne internet-predstavnyctvo Prezydenta Ukrajiny. Oficijne internet-predstavnyctvo Prezydenta Ukrajiny. Available from : https://www.president.gov.ua/documents/362022-41285 (data zvernennja 06.10.2024).

Pro vnesennja zmin do dejakykh zakonodavchykh aktiv Ukrajiny shhodo okremykh pytanj prokhodzhennja vijsjkovoji sluzhby, mobilizaciji ta vijsjkovogho obliku. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3633-20#Text (data zvernennja: 08.09.2024).

Pro vijsjkovyj obov'jazok i vijsjkovu sluzhbu. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2232-12#n1713 (data zvernennja: 09.09.2024).

Mahal. Available from : https://www.mahal.org.il/en/Pages/default.aspx (date of access: 08.10.2024).

Michalowski M. How Much Data Is Generated Every Day in 2024? Spacelift. Available from : https://spacelift.io/blog/how-much-data-is-generated-every-day (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).

Hegel, G. W. F. Phenomenology of spirit. Trans. AV Miller/Oxford: Oxford UP. 1977. Available from : https://doi.org/10.1515/9780822390169-005 (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).

Pro zatverdzhennja Ukazu Prezydenta Ukrajiny “Pro prodovzhennja stroku diji vojennogho stanu v Ukrajini”. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3891-20#Text (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).

Pro mobilizacijnu pidghotovku ta mobilizaciju. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3543-12#Text (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).

Zvernennia Prezydentky Yevropeiskoi Komisii Ursuly fon der Liaien na Vsesvitnomu ekonomichnomu forumi. World Economic Forum. Davos, 16.01.2024. Available from : https://www.weforum.org/meetings/world-economic-forum-annual-meeting-2024/sessions/special-address-by-ursula-von-der-leyen-president-of-the-european-commission-96293a5a9d/ (data zvernennia: 06.10.2024).

World Bank Open Data. World Bank Open Data. Available from : https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD (date of access: 05.09.2024).

Ministerstvo Finansiv Ukrajiny. Ministerstvo Finansiv Ukrajiny. Available from : https://mof.gov.ua/uk/news/derzhavnii_ta_garantovanii_derzhavoiu_borg_ukraini_z_pochatku_2024_roku_stav_deshevshim_na_ponad_10-4741 (data zvernennja: 09.09.2024).

Ukrinform. Deficyt bjudzhetu cjoghorich ochikujetjsja na rivni 20,7% VVP – Nacbank. Ukrinform, 03.05.2024. Available from : https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-economy/3859580-deficit-budzetu-cogoric-ocikuetsa-na-rivni-207-vvp-nacbank.html (data zvernennja 12.10.2024).

Shhomisjachnyj makroekonomichnyj ta monetarnyj oghljad. Kyjiv : Departament monetar. polityky ta ekon. analizu NBU, veresenj 2024. 32 s. Available from : https://bank.gov.ua/admin_uploads/article/MMR_2024-09.pdf?v=9

Ekonomichna pravda. V Ukrajini istorychnyj rozryv mizh eksportom ta importom. Prote je i pozytyvni novyny. Ekonomichna pravda. Available from : https://www.epravda.com.ua/weeklycharts/2024/05/16/713755/ (data zvernennja: 12.10.2024).

Ghrushecjkyj A. Pres-relizy ta zvity – Dynamika doviry socialjnym instytucijam u 2021-2023 rokakh. Domashnja storinka KMIS, 18.12.2023. Available from : https://www.kiis.com.ua/?lang=ukr&cat=reports&id=1335&page=1 (data zvernennja 06.10.2024).

Adaptacija veteraniv vijny do myrnogho zhyttja: pomichnyk veterana. Domashnja storinka NISD, 06.11.2023. Available from : https://niss.gov.ua/news/komentari-ekspertiv/adaptatsiya-veteraniv-viyny-do-myrnoho-zhyttya-pomichnyk-veterana (data zvernennja 10.11.2024).

Vojtovsjkyj K. Dosvid Izrajilju shhodo formuvannja strateghiji nacionaljnoji bezpeky. Domashnja storinka NISD, 17.06.2022. Available from : https://niss.gov.ua/doslidzhennya/natsionalna-bezpeka/dosvid-izrayilyu-shchodo-formuvannya-stratehiyi-natsionalnoyi (data zvernennja 10.11.2024).

Varnalii Z., Bilyk R., Khmelevskiy M. Social security of Ukraine: summary, problems and ways of ensuring. University Economic Bulletin. 2020. No. 45. P. 105–114. https://doi.org/10.31470/2306-546x-2020-45-105-114 (date of access: 11.10.2024).

Kodeks zakoniv pro pracju Ukrajiny. Portal Federaciji metalurghiv Ukrajiny, 19.02.2019. Available from : http://fedmet.org/analytics/kodeks-zakoniv-pro-pracyu-ukraini/ (data zvernennja 10.11.2024).

Komissarova N., Komissarov M., Sharko D. Pytannja socialjnogho zabezpechennja vijsjkovosluzhbovciv: pravovi ta jurydychni aspekty. Naukovi innovaciji ta peredovi tekhnologhiji 2024. №5(33). 1489 s. Available from : http://socrates.vsau.org/repository/getfile.php/36064.pdf (data zvernennja 06.10.2024).

Pro pererakhunok pensij osobam, jaki zviljneni z vijsjkovoji sluzhby, ta dejakym inshym kateghorijam osib. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/103-2018-p#Text (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).

Pro pensijne zabezpechennja osib, zviljnenykh z vijsjkovoji sluzhby, ta dejakykh inshykh osib. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2262-12#Text (data zvernennja 11.10.2024).

Upovnovazhenyj Verkhovnoji Rady Ukrajiny z prav ljudyny – Gholovna. Available from : https://www.ombudsman.gov.ua/storage/app/media/pensiyne-zabezpechennya.pdf (data zvernennja 11.10.2024).

Syly bezpeky i oborony informujutj shhodo novogho porjadku narakhuvannja ghroshovogho zabezpechennja. Radware Captcha Page, 31.12.2023. Available from : https://www.kmu.gov.ua/news/syly-bezpeky-i-oborony-informuiut-shchodo-novoho-poriadku-narakhuvannia-hroshovoho-zabezpechennia (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).

Bjelousov V. D. Osoblyvi pryncypy socialjnoji bezpeky suchasnoji Ukrajiny. Aktualjni problemy prava: teorija i praktyka. 2024. № 47. S. 26–35. https://doi.org/10.33216/2218-5461/2024-47-1-26-35 (data zvernennja: 11.09.2024).

Andalicjka I. Chy mozhlyva zaraz obov'jazkova mobilizacija zhinok v Ukrajini: nardep projasnyv sytuaciju. Informacijne aghentstvo UNIAN, 18.10.24 Available from : https://www.unian.ua/politics/chi-mozhliva-zaraz-obov-yazkova-mobilizaciya-zhinok-v-ukrajini-nardep-proyasniv-situaciyu-12791394.html?_gl=1*h0zzi1*_ga*MjAwMDk2OTIzMS4xNzI4MzI4NTM3*_ga_TECJ2YKWSJ*MTcyOTQ0MDI0NS4yLjAuMTcyOTQ0MDI0NS42MC4wLjA.*_ga_DENC12J6P3*MTcyOTQ0MDI0NS4yLjAuMTcyOTQ0MDI0NS42MC4wLjE2MzE1MDQwMg.

Pavlushenko S., Lysenko D. Dosvid pidtrymannja ta vidnovlennja moraljno-psykhologhichnogho stanu vijsjkovosluzhbovciv vijsjkovykh chastyn (pidrozdiliv) Zbrojnykh Syl Ukrajiny pid chas rosijsjko-ukrajinsjkoji vijny: informacijno-analitychni materialy. Kyjiv : NUOU, 2023. 28 s.

Eric Ciaramella Envisioning a Long-Term Security Arrangement for Ukraine. The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 08.06.2023 32 s. Available from : https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2023/06/envisioning-a-long-term-security-arrangement-for-ukraine?lang=en (data zvernennja 06.10.2024).

Joint Statement of the Leaders of India, Israel, United Arab Emirates, and the United States (I2U2) | The White House. The White House. Available from : https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/07/14/joint-statement-of-the-leaders-of-india-israel-united-arab-emirates-and-the-united-states-i2u2/

Navitj najghirsha ughoda Ukrajiny z RF bude krashhoju za nynishnju sytuaciju – Tramp na peredvyborchomu vystupi. Informacijne aghentstvo Interfaks-Ukrajina. 26.09.2024. Available from : https://interfax.com.ua/news/political/1016467.html

Pro nadannia hryfa onovlenym navchalnym prohramam : Nakaz M-va osvity i nauky Ukrainy № 698 Ofitsiinyi vebportal MON Ukrainy. Available from : https://mon.gov.ua/npa/pro-nadannya-grifa-onovlenim-navchalnim-programam (data zvernennia 08.09.2024)

Byelik A. O. Analiz derzhavnoji polityky zabezpechennja ekonomichnoji bezpeky : kvalifikacijna naukova pracja na pravakh rukopysu. Kyjiv : NADU, 2016. 102 s.

The World Factbook, Israel. CIA. Available from : https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/countries/israel/

Kushh. O. Fenomen Izrajilju, abo Jak vyzhyvaty v nespryjatlyvykh umovakh. GhLAVKOM. Available from : https://glavcom.ua/columns/olexkush/fenomen-izrajilju-abo-jak-vizhivati-v-nesprijatlivikh-umovakh-961329.html (data zvernennja: 11.10.2024).

Kravchenko O. Izrajilj pokhvalyvsja pokaznykamy pryrostu naselennja za 2021 rik. GhLAVKOM. Available from : https://glavcom.ua/world/observe/izrajil-pohvalivsya-pokaznikami-prirostu-naselennya-za-2021-rik-810782.html (data zvernennja: 11.10.2024).

Smertnistj v Ukrajini. Opendatabot. Available from : https://opendatabot.ua/open/death-statistics (data zvernennja: 11.10.2024).

Byelik A. O. Konversija vojennoji ekonomiky v period perekhodu do rynkovykh vidnosyn : kvalifikacijna naukova pracja na pravakh rukopysu. Kyiv : VIKNU, 2005. 60 s.

Terent'jeva A. Dosvid Derzhavy Izrajilj shhodo upravlinnja bezpekoju cyviljnogho naselennja v umovakh kryzovykh sytuacij. Naukovyj visnyk: Derzhavne upravlinnja. 2023. # 2 (14). S. 310–333. https://doi.org/10.33269/2618-0065-2023-2(14)-310-333

Pro nacionaljnu bezpeku Ukrajiny. Oficijnyj vebportal parlamentu Ukrajiny. Available from : https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2469-19#Text (data zvernennja: 06.10.2024).


Abstract views: 66
PDF Downloads: 30
Published
2025-04-30
How to Cite
Byelik, A. (2025). The The Relativeness of Risks and Threats to Implementation of the (Military) Personnel Policy of Ukraine and the State of Israel Citizens in Terms of (Military) Training. Social Development and Security, 15(2), 95-118. https://doi.org/10.33445/sds.2025.15.2.9
Section
Military Security