Historical Transformation of the Concept of Battle Formations: from the First Mentions to Decentralized and Multi-Domain Systems in Modern Doctrines

Keywords: Armed Forces of Ukraine, Battle Formation, Multi-Domain Operation, NATO Standards, Network-Centricity, Adaptive Combat Environment

Abstract

Purpose. To conduct a retrospective analysis of the evolution of battle formations from the static linear formations of the eighteenth century to modern multi-domain systems and to substantiate the need to refine the concept of “battle formation” in Ukrainian military science by shifting from a geometric interpretation to the concept of a multi-domain adaptive combat system.

Materials and methods. The study employed historical-genetic, problem-chronological, historical-systemic methods, as well as content analysis of doctrinal documents. The research covers the period from the mid-eighteenth century to the present. Doctrines, strategies, and combat regulations of the United States, the United Kingdom, Finland, Sweden, Israel, China, Iran, Ukraine, and the Russian Federation were analyzed. The comparison was conducted according to the criteria of spatial organization, functional structure, autonomy, command and control, information integration, dispersion, and synchronization of effects.

Results. The study identified the transformation of battle formations from linear troop formations into dynamic, modular, and multi-domain systems. A terminological and conceptual inconsistency was identified between the contemporary nature of combat operations and the current definition of “battle formation” in Ukrainian combat regulations. The study substantiates the expediency of interpreting the concept as a “multi-domain adaptive combat system”.

Theoretical value. The evolution of approaches to understanding battle formations was systematized, and a conceptual approach to their multidimensional interpretation as a dynamic configuration of forces, assets, and information and command-and-control links was further developed.

Article type: theoretical and analytical article.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Shuhalii, Ye. P. (2016). Zahalna taktyka “Mekhanizovanyi (tankovyi) batalion v zahalnoviiskovomu boiu”: Kurs lektsii [General tactics “Mechanized (tank) battalion in combined arms combat”: Course of lectures]. MP Lesia.

Lobko, M. M. (2021). Obiednana operatsiia yak osnovna forma vidsichi zbroinii ahresii “hibrydnoho” typu [Joint operation as the main form of countering “hybrid” armed aggression]. Nauka i oborona, (2), 24–33. https://doi.org/10.33099/2618-1614-2021-15-2-24-33

Tsentr doslidzhen voiennoi istorii Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. (n.d.). Operatsiia z prykryttia derzhavnoho kordonu v sektori “D”. Starobesheve [Operation to cover the state border in Sector “D”: Starobesheve]. https://milhistory.zsu.gov.ua/ato-oos/operaciya-z-prykryttia-derzhavnoho-kordonu-v-sektori-d-starobesheve

Lutsyshyn, A. M., Soldatenkov, O. A., Cherepian, Yu. I., & Totrov, H. M. (2026). Suchasni zminy u taktytsi dii pidrozdiliv Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy na osnovi analizu boiovoho dosvidu rosiisko-ukrainskoi viiny [Contemporary changes in the tactics of units of the Armed Forces of Ukraine based on the analysis of combat experience of the Russian-Ukrainian war]. Natsionalni interesy, 4(21), 473–481. https://perspectives.pp.ua/index.php/niu/article/view/41414/41428

Zabolotniuk, V. I., & Martsinko, N. M. (2025). Mali mashyny velykoi viiny: Tekhnichna revoliutsiia, FPV-drony ta mobilni inzhenerni rishennia u transformatsii oboronnoi taktyky v umovakh obmezhenykh resursiv [Small machines of a great war: Technological revolution, FPV drones, and mobile engineering solutions in the transformation of defensive tactics under limited resources]. Viiskovo-tekhnichnyi zbirnyk, 33(2), 154–160. https://doi.org/10.33577/2312-4458.33.2025.154-160

Frederick II the Great. (1940). Viiskovi nastanovlennia [Military instructions]. Derzhvydav.

Guibert, J. A. (1772). Essai général de tactique: Précédé d'un discours sur l'état actuel de la politique et de la science militaire en Europe. Chez les Libraires Associés.

Napoleon I Bonaparte. (1956). O voennom iskusstve: Izbrannye proizvedeniia [On the art of war: Selected works] (P. A. Zhilin, Comp.). Voenizdat.

Napoleon I Bonaparte. (2015). Maksymy: Viiskovi zapovidi velykoho polkovodtsia [Maxims: Military precepts of the great commander]. Vydavets FOP Stebeliak.

Jomini, A. H. (1939). Narys viiskovoho mystetstva [The art of war]. Voenizdat.

Clausewitz, C. von. (2018). Pro viinu [On war]. Vydavnytstvo Zhupanskoho.

Svechin, O. A. (2003). Stratehiia [Strategy]. Kuchkovo pole.

Triandafillov, V. K. (1929). Kharakter operatsii suchasnykh armii [The nature of operations of modern armies]. Derzhvydav.

Isserson, H. S. (1932). Evoliutsiia operatyvnoho mystetstva [The evolution of operational art]. Derzhvydav.

Guderian, H. (2005). Uvaha, tanky! Istoriia stvorennia tankovykh viisk [Attention, tanks! The history of the creation of tank forces]. Tsentrpolihraf.

Liddell Hart, B. H. (1999). Stratehiia nepriamykh dii [Strategy of indirect approach]. Osnovy.

Department of the Army. (1986). FM 100-5: Operations. Headquarters, Department of the Army.

Security Committee. (2025). The security strategy for society 2025: Government resolution. https://turvallisuuskomitea.fi/

Prime Minister’s Office. (2020). Government report on Finnish foreign and security policy.

Ministry of Defence of Finland. (2017). National defence strategy.

Iso-Markku, T., & Müller-Wille, T. (2023). Finland’s NATO accession: What will change? (FIIA Briefing Paper No. 334). Finnish Institute of International Affairs. https://fiia.fi/en/publication/finlands-nato-accession

Finnish Defence Forces. (2017). Field manual 2017. Edita Publishing.

Swedish Armed Forces. (2016). Military strategy doctrine 2016 (MSD 16). Försvarsmakten.

Israel Defense Forces. (2015). The IDF strategy. General Staff IDF.

Kochavi, A. (2020). The “Tnufa” operational concept: The multi-dimensional counter-terrorism campaign. IDF General Staff.

Academy of Military Science. (2013). The science of military strategy. Military Science Press.

Academy of Military Science. (2006). The science of campaigns. Military Science Press.

People’s Liberation Army. (2011). Science of tactics. Military Science Press.

Department of the Army. (2022). FM 3-0: Operations.

Department of the Army. (2021). FM 3-94: Armies, corps, and division operations.

Department of the Army. (2023). FM 3-90: Tactics.

Connell, M. (2010). Iranian military strategy and doctrine. United States Institute of Peace.

Ministry of Defence. (2022). Army doctrine publication: Land operations. Development, Concepts and Doctrine Centre.

Ministerstvo oborony Rossiiskoi Federatsii. (2019). Boevoi ustav Sukhoputnykh voisk. Chast 1 (diviziia, brigada, polk) [Combat regulations of the Ground Forces. Part 1 (division, brigade, regiment)] (Prikaz Ministra oborony RF No. 07).

Komanduvannia Sukhoputnykh viisk Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. (2026). Boiovyi statut mekhanizovanykh i tankovykh viisk Sukhoputnykh viisk Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. Chastyna I (bryhada, polk): SBP 3-(01,02,04).55 [Combat regulations of the mechanized and tank troops of the Ground Forces of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Part I (brigade, regiment)].

Komanduvannia Sukhoputnykh viisk Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. (2026). Boiovyi statut Sukhoputnykh viisk Zbroinykh Syl Ukrainy. Chastyna II (mekhanizovanyi batalion): SBP 3-(01).56 [Combat regulations of the Ground Forces of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Part II (mechanized battalion)].


Abstract views: 4
PDF Downloads: 1
Published
2026-10-31
How to Cite
Zhuchkov, A. (2026). Historical Transformation of the Concept of Battle Formations: from the First Mentions to Decentralized and Multi-Domain Systems in Modern Doctrines. Social Development and Security, 16(5), 569-587. https://doi.org/10.33445/sds.2026.16.5.28
Section
Support of Military Forces