Alternatives to Military Service in Israel: Lessons for Ukraine

Keywords: freedom of conscience, alternative non-military service, exemption from military service, verification of religious beliefs, Israel, Haredim, mobilisation

Abstract

Purpose: The purpose of the study is a comprehensive analysis of the Israeli system of non-military forms of discharging military duty and of the mechanisms for verifying religious beliefs, and the formulation on this basis of conclusions for Ukraine in the context of the Russian-Ukrainian war. A separate task is the terminological delimitation of five distinct legal institutions that are frequently conflated in Ukrainian and foreign literature under the general heading of "alternative service".

Methodology: The study applies historical-legal, formal-legal and comparative-legal methods, deductive typology construction, and single-case analysis with within-case variation. The source base comprises the Defence Service Law of the State of Israel (Consolidated Version) 5746-1986, the Basic Law: Torah Study of 2026, Amendment No. 28 to the Defence Service Law, judgments of the High Court of Justice, reports of the State Comptroller of Israel, US Department of State International Religious Freedom reports, documents of the UN Human Rights Committee, Venice Commission opinion CDL-AD(2025)005, Ukrainian legislation and orders of the State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience.

Findings: It is established that Israel does not have compulsory alternative non-military service in the Ukrainian and European sense. All four Israeli mechanisms built around religious grounds lead to exemption or deferral without any reciprocal obligation, while national service (Sherut Leumi) is a voluntary programme for persons already exempted. The typology of verification mechanisms is derived deductively from two binary axes — the object of examination and the mode of establishment — yielding exactly four logically possible constructions. It is shown that Israeli experience is suitable for adoption with respect to the verification of grounds and the accommodation of service conditions, but not as a model for substituting military duty.

Theoretical implications: A five-part taxonomy of legal responses to religious objection to military service and a deductively derived typology of verification mechanisms are proposed. It is argued that a mechanism's long-term capacity for correction is determined by the presence of repeated verification during the period in which the right is enjoyed.

Practical implications: Five recommendations for Ukraine are formulated. It is established that Ukraine already possesses two functioning status-based mechanisms for verifying religious grounds that operate under martial law — the reservation of clergy and the deferral for students — and that it is their architecture, rather than Israeli institutions, that offers the closest reference point for designing wartime alternative service.

Originality/value: For the first time in Ukrainian scholarship it is demonstrated that the widespread notion of Israeli "alternative service" is inaccurate, and an analytical apparatus is proposed enabling correct comparison of the institutions of the two legal orders.

Limitations/future research: Hebrew-language primary sources are used through English translations and analytical summaries. The situation in both states as of July 2026 remains in active transformation. Comparison with the models of Finland, Greece and the Republic of Korea is a promising direction.

Type of Article: theoretical (historical-legal, comparative-legal).

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. (1996). Konstytutsiia Ukrainy [Constitution of Ukraine]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254%D0%BA/96-%D0%B2%D1%80

Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. (1991). Zakon Ukrainy “Pro alternatyvnu (neviiskovu) sluzhbu” No. 1975-XII [Law of Ukraine “On Alternative (Non-Military) Service” No. 1975-XII]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1975-12

Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. (2024). Zakon Ukrainy No. 3633-IX pro vnesennia zmin do deiakykh zakonodavchykh aktiv Ukrainy shchodo okremykh pytan prokhodzhennia viiskovoi sluzhby, mobilizatsii ta viiskovoho obliku [Law of Ukraine No. 3633-IX]. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3633-20

ZMINA. (2025, November 10). Proty “Svidkiv Yehovy” v Ukraini vidkryly ponad tysiachu kryminalnykh sprav za vidmovu mobilizuvatysia [More than a thousand criminal cases were opened against Jehovah’s Witnesses in Ukraine for refusing mobilisation]. https://zmina.info/news/proty-svidkiv-yegovy-v-ukrayini-vidkryly-ponad-tysyachu-kryminalnyh-sprav-za-vidmovu-mobilizuvatysya-sergij-rabinovich/

Supreme Court of Ukraine. (2024). Vysnovok Ob’iednanoi palaty Kasatsiinoho kryminalnoho sudu shchodo relihiinykh perekonan ta statti 336 Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy [Conclusion of the Joint Chamber of the Cassation Criminal Court on religious beliefs and Article 336 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine]. https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pres-centr/news/1602486/

Venice Commission. (2025). Ukraine — Amicus curiae brief for the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on alternative (non-military) service (CDL-AD(2025)005). https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-AD(2025)005-e

European Commission. (2025). Ukraine 2025 report: Communication on EU enlargement policy. https://enlargement.ec.europa.eu/document/download/ukraine-report-2025

Yelenskyi, V. (2026, June 7). Interv’iu holovy Derzhavnoi sluzhby Ukrainy z etnopolityky ta svobody sovisti [Interview with the Head of the State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience]. Interfax-Ukraine. https://interfax.com.ua/news/interview/1173988.html

Constitutional Court of Ukraine. (2026). Zamina vykonannia viiskovoho obov’iazku pid chas mobilizatsii na alternatyvnu (neviiskovu) sluzhbu: sud rozhliadaie spravy [Replacement of military duty during mobilisation with alternative (non-military) service: The Court considers the cases]. https://ccu.gov.ua/novyna/zamina-vykonannya-viyskovogo-obovyazku-pid-chas-mobilizaciyi-na-alternatyvnu-neviyskovu

Amnesty International. (1999). The price of principles: Imprisonment of conscientious objectors. https://www.refworld.org/reference/countryrep/amnesty/1999/en/39893

UN Human Rights Committee. (1993). General comment No. 22: Article 18 (Freedom of thought, conscience or religion) (CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.4). https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/general-comments-and-recommendations/ccprc21rev1add4-general-comment-no-22-article-18

UN Commission on Human Rights. (1998). Resolution 1998/77: Conscientious objection to military service. https://ap.ohchr.org/documents/E/CHR/resolutions/E-CN_4-RES-1998-77.doc

Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers. (2010). Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)4 on human rights of members of the armed forces. https://search.coe.int/cm/Pages/result_details.aspx?ObjectID=09000016805cdd35

Bayatyan v. Armenia, Application No. 23459/03, Grand Chamber judgment of 7 July 2011. European Court of Human Rights. https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-105566

Erçep v. Turkey, Application No. 43965/04, judgment of 22 November 2011. European Court of Human Rights. https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-107532

Savda v. Turkey, Application No. 42730/05, judgment of 12 June 2012. European Court of Human Rights. https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-111414

Papavasilakis v. Greece, Application No. 66899/14, judgment of 15 September 2016. European Court of Human Rights. https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-166693

Dyagilev v. Russia, Application No. 49972/16, judgment of 10 March 2020. European Court of Human Rights. https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng?i=001-201649

Levy, Y. (2007). Israel’s materialist militarism. Lexington Books.

Levy, Y. (2019). Whose life is worth more? Hierarchies of risk and death in contemporary wars. Stanford University Press.

Livny, A. (2018). Conscientious objection and the state: Contextualizing the Israeli case. Armed Forces & Society, 44(4), 666–687.

Stadler, N., & Ben-Ari, E. (2003). Other-worldly soldiers? Ultra-Orthodox views of military service in contemporary Israel. Israel Affairs, 9(4), 17–48. https://doi.org/10.1080/13537120412331321513

Tiargan-Orr, R., & Eran-Jona, M. (2016). The Israeli public’s perception of the IDF: Stability and change. Armed Forces & Society, 42(2), 324–343. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095327X15592214

Weiss, E. (2012). Principle or pathology? Adjudicating the right to conscience in the Israeli military. American Anthropologist, 114(1), 81–94. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1548-1433.2011.01398.x

Weiss, E. (2014). Conscientious objectors in Israel: Citizenship, sacrifice, trials of fealty. University of Pennsylvania Press.

Zonschein v. Judge Advocate General, HCJ 7622/02, judgment of 23 November 2002. Supreme Court of Israel.

Sagi, A., & Shapira, R. (2002). Civil disobedience and conscientious objection. Israel Law Review, 36(3), 181–217. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021223700018021

Harel, A. (2002). Unconscionable objection to conscientious objection: Notes on Sagi and Shapira. Israel Law Review, 36(3), 219–226.

Enoch, D. (2002). Some arguments against conscientious objection and civil disobedience refuted. Israel Law Review, 36(3), 227–253. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0021223700018045

Hammer, L. (1993). Conscientious objection to military service in Israel: Does the individual stand a chance? NYLS Journal of International and Comparative Law, 14(2), 137–171. https://digitalcommons.nyls.edu/journal_of_international_and_comparative_law/vol14/iss2/4

Mokhonchuk, B., & Kovtunenko, O. (2025). Alternatyvna sluzhba z mirkuvan sovisti: mizhnarodni standarty, sudova praktyka, problemy. Konstytutsiine pravo, (1), 61–78. https://www.constjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/issues/2025-1/pdfs/5-bohdan-mokhonchuk-oleksandra-kovtunenko-alternatyvna-sluzhba-mirkuvan-sovisti-mizhnarodni-standarty-sudova-praktyka-problemy.pdf

Pyroha, I. S., Bielova, M. V., & Fridmanska, V. I. (2025). Alternatyvna (neviiskova) sluzhba v umovakh voiennoho stanu. Naukovyi visnyk Uzhhorodskoho natsionalnoho universytetu. Seriia: Pravo, (56), 345–351. https://visnyk-juris-uzhnu.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/56-1.pdf

Shany, Y., & Lavi, M. (2024, March 7). Development of the Haredi exemption law. Israel Democracy Institute. https://en.idi.org.il/articles/53301

Mishpacha. (2024, March 12). Timeline of a crisis. https://mishpacha.com/timeline-of-a-crisis/

Cohen, S. A. (2008). Israel and its army: From cohesion to confusion. Routledge.

Helman, S. (1999). Negotiating obligations, creating rights: Conscientious objection and the redefinition of citizenship in Israel. Citizenship Studies, 3(1), 45–70.

Ressler v. Minister of Defence, HCJ 910/86, judgment of 12 June 1988. Supreme Court of Israel. https://versa.cardozo.yu.edu/opinions/ressler-v-minister-defence

Rubinstein v. Minister of Defense, HCJ 3267/97, judgment of 9 December 1998. Supreme Court of Israel. https://versa.cardozo.yu.edu/opinions/rubinstein-v-minister-defense

Library of Congress. (2014, April 2). Israel: New law on national civilian service obligations for yeshiva students. Global Legal Monitor. https://www.loc.gov/item/global-legal-monitor/2014-04-02/israel-new-law-on-national-civilian-service-obligations-for-yeshiva-students

Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. (2013). The Druze in Israel and the question of compulsory military service. https://jcfa.org/article/the-druze-in-israel-and-the-question-of-compulsory-military-service/

Peled, A. (1998). A question of loyalty: Military manpower policy in multiethnic states. Cornell University Press.

The Times of Israel. (2025a). Katz said to reject IDF request to extend hesder yeshiva soldiers’ service. https://www.timesofisrael.com/katz-said-to-reject-idf-request-to-extend-hesder-yeshiva-soldiers-service/

Central Bureau of Statistics of Israel. (2025). Statistical abstract of Israel 2025. https://www.cbs.gov.il/en/publications/Pages/2025/Statistical-Abstract-of-Israel-2025-No-76.aspx

Israel Democracy Institute. (2025). Statistical report on ultra-Orthodox society in Israel 2025. https://en.idi.org.il/haredi/2025

Pew Research Center. (2025, March 26). Four facts about religious switching within Judaism in Israel. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/03/26/4-facts-about-religious-switching-within-judaism-in-israel/

Sokol, S. (2025b, November 28). Bismuth presents bill exempting yeshiva students from IDF draft, loosening sanctions. The Times of Israel. https://www.timesofisrael.com/bismuth-presents-bill-exempting-yeshiva-students-from-idf-draft-loosening-sanctions/

Jewish Virtual Library. (2025). Vital statistics: Latest population statistics for Israel. https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/latest-population-statistics-for-israel

Israel National News. (2026b, July 13). Knesset passes Basic Law of Torah Study. https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/430101

Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. (1999). Postanova No. 2066 pro zatverdzhennia normatyvno-pravovykh aktiv shchodo zastosuvannia Zakonu Ukrainy “Pro alternatyvnu (neviiskovu) sluzhbu”. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2066-99-%D0%BF

Defence Service Law [Consolidated Version], 5746-1986 (Israel), with subsequent amendments.

Shany, Y., & Lavi, M. (2026, January 21). Conscription of Haredi yeshiva students to the IDF and the emerging constitutional crisis. Israel Democracy Institute. https://en.idi.org.il/articles/63168

Israel National News. (2026a, July 12). Text of law to curb arrest of Haredi draft evaders disclosed. https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/429742

Verkhovna Rada Ukrainy. (1993). Zakon Ukrainy “Pro mobilizatsiinu pidhotovku ta mobilizatsiiu” No. 3543-XII. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3543-12

State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience. (2025). Nakaz No. N-21/11 vid 5 liutoho 2025 roku pro zatverdzhennia Kryteriiv, za yakymy otsiniuietsia stupin krytychnosti relihiinoi orhanizatsii. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua

State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience. (2026). Nakaz No. N-72/11 vid 8 travnia 2026 roku pro vnesennia zmin do Pereliku yurydychnykh osib — relihiinykh orhanizatsii, yaki nalezhat do krytychno vazhlyvykh. https://dess.gov.ua

Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. (2024). Postanova No. 560 vid 16 travnia 2024 roku “Pro zatverdzhennia Poriadku provedennia pryzovu hromadian na viiskovu sluzhbu pid chas mobilizatsii, na osoblyvyi period”. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/560-2024-%D0%BF

The Jerusalem Post. (2021, July 5). FADC fights over religious women’s army exemptions. https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/fadc-debates-religious-women-exemption-from-idf-672857

Sokol, S. (2025a, April 2). Just 2% of Haredi call-ups have enlisted since High Court struck down their exemptions. The Times of Israel. https://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/just-2-of-haredi-call-ups-have-enlisted-since-high-court-struck-down-their-exemptions/

Malach, G. (2025, May 15). The latest Haredi enlistment targets: Insufficient and ineffectual. Israel Democracy Institute. https://en.idi.org.il/articles/59374

State Comptroller of Israel. (2018, March 14). Annual report on supervision of yeshiva students receiving service deferrals. https://www.mevaker.gov.il/En/publication/Pages/default.aspx

UN Human Rights Committee. (2014). Concluding observations on the fourth periodic report of Israel (CCPR/C/ISR/CO/4). https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-180034/

Israel National News. (2024). IDF drafts new guidelines on kashrut, prayer, and Shabbat for soldiers. https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/415010

Israel National News. (2026c). Chief Rabbi: No blanket permit to break Shabbat for morale. https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/429917

The Times of Israel. (2025b). First 50 ultra-Orthodox soldiers drafted to IDF’s new Haredi brigade. https://www.timesofisrael.com/first-50-ultra-orthodox-soldiers-drafted-to-idfs-new-haredi-brigade/

The Times of Israel. (2024, September 7). Meet the young men and women performing 38 million hours of national service a year. https://www.timesofisrael.com/meet-the-young-men-and-women-performing-38-million-hours-of-national-service-a-year/

Jehovah’s Witnesses. (2025). Israel: Country statistics and historic milestones. https://www.jw.org/en/news/region/israel/historic-milestones-israel/

Adventist Yearbook. (2024). Israel Field. General Conference of Seventh-day Adventists. https://www.adventistyearbook.org/entity?EntityID=12887

Elofer, R. (2011). Impact of immigration on Israel. Journal of Adventist Mission Studies, 7(2), 62–74. https://digitalcommons.andrews.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1010&context=jams

Forward. (2016, December 6). Inside the insular world of Israeli Jews who became Jehovah’s Witnesses. https://forward.com/news/356003/inside-the-insular-world-of-israeli-jews-who-became-jehovahs-witnesses/

U.S. Department of State. (2016). International religious freedom report: Israel and the occupied territories. https://2021-2025.state.gov/report/custom/da9470f20f/

Interfax-Ukraine. (2026, May 12). Krytychno vazhlyvymy v Ukraini ye 10,9 tys. relihiinykh orhanizatsii — onovlenyi perelik Derzhetnopolityky. https://interfax.com.ua/news/general/1166507.html

Dnipropetrovsk District Administrative Court. (2024). Rishennia vid 3 hrudnia 2024 roku u spravi No. 160/27062/24. Yedynyi derzhavnyi reiestr sudovykh rishen. https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/123471935

Kotylko, Y. (2026). Alternative Civilian Service in Russia during the Russian-Ukrainian War: Between Constitutional Guarantee, Mobilization Practice and International Legal Criticism. Social Development and Security, 16(3), 77-101. https://doi.org/10.33445/sds.2026.16.3.6.


Abstract views: 4
PDF Downloads: 2
Published
2026-09-22
How to Cite
Kotylko, Y. (2026). Alternatives to Military Service in Israel: Lessons for Ukraine. Social Development and Security, 16(5), 37-71. https://doi.org/10.33445/sds.2026.16.5.2
Section
National and State Security Studies