Analysis of historical ways of economic support of war of the end of XVIII – early XIX century in the context of the French-Russian war of 1812-1814
Abstract
Purpose: the purpose of the article is to analyze some historical methods of economic support of the wars of the late XVIII – early XIX centuries to determine the features of the economic support of the wars inherent in the analyzed period.
Design/Method/Approach: to achieve the goal of the study, its decomposition was carried out and the following was investigated: the development of economic theory at the end of the XVIII century – the beginning of the XIX century; certain methods of economic security, typical of the Russian Empire in the early XIX century; certain methods of economic security are inherent in the French Empire of the late XVIII century – early XIX century. Finally, some features of the historical methods of economic support of the war, inherent in the subject period, have been systematically identified during the study. Methods of analysis and synthesis became the methodological tools of the study.
Findings: the article analyzes the development of economic theory of the late XVIII century – the beginning of the XIX century; analyzed some ways of economic support inherent in the French and Russian empires at the beginning of the XIX century; the historical features of the methods of economic support of the war, inherent in the period of research, are singled out.
Theoretical implications: according to the results of the research, the existing theory of military economics has been improved in the context of highlighting a number of features in the methods of economic support of the war of the late XVIII – early XIX centuries on the example of the Franco-Russian war of 1812-1814. The results of the research can be useful for scholars in the fields of military economics and history and used in relevant fields of research.
Practical implications: the article highlights and identifies the historical features of the methods of economic support of the war, inherent in the study period.
Originality/Value: the scientific novelty of the study is to determine the features of historical methods of economic support of the war, inherent in the subject period considered in the study.
Research limitations/Future research: the limitation of the study is to take into account the ways of economic support of the war of the late XVIII – early XIX centuries on the example of the Franco-Russian war of 1812-1814. The end of the XVIII century was chosen as the research period - the beginning of the XIX century, the object of study – the French and Russian empires, the highest level of military power and economic opportunities. The following issues are considered promising for further research: coverage of ways of economic security in later historical periods (the First and Second World Wars) to establish their features and substantiate trends in the development of ways of economic security of wars; analysis of the current state of functioning of enterprises of the defense-industrial complex of Ukraine; study of the mechanism of formation and implementation of mobilization tasks in the course of meeting the needs of defense to identify their features and development trends.
Papertype: theoretical
Downloads
References
Global Firepower. 2022 Military Strength Ranking. Available from : https://www.globalfirepower.com/countries-listing.php (дата звернення 01.02.2022).
Lind, William S., John F. Schmitt, and Gary I. Wilson, “Fourth generation warfare: Another look”. (Marine Corps Gazette 85, no. 11, 2001), p. 69.
Lind, William S. (January 15, 2004), “Understanding Fourth Generation War”, antiwar.com, retrieved February 7, 2010
William S. Lind, LtCol. Gregory A. Thiele, USMC; 4th Generation Warfare Handbook, Castalia House.
Smit A. Roz·hlyad pryrody ta prychyn bahat·stva narodiv [Consideration of the nature and causes of the wealth of nations]. Litres, 2021.
Chanh KH. YU. Ekonomika. Instruktsiya z vykorystannya [Economy. Instructions for use] / per. z anhl. Andriy Lapin. 3-tye vyd. Kyiv: Nash format, 2018. 400 s.
List Fridrikh. Natsionalʹna systema politychnoyi ekonomiyi [National system of political economy] / per. z nim. Mykhaylo Havrysh. – K.: Nash Format, 2021. – 368
Mondeya K. “Vid voyennoyi do ekonomichnoyi nauky. Viyna ta myr u svitospryynyatti E. F. Kankrina” [From military to economic science. War and peace in the worldview of E.F. Kankrin].
Cancrin. Fragmente über die Kriegskunst, nach Gesichtspunkten der militärischen Philosophie. St. Petersburg, 1809. S. 57–85.
Kankrín Ye. F. O voyennoy ekonomii vo vremya mira i voyny i yeye otnoshenii k voyennym operatsiyam”, 1820–1823 [On military economy during peace and war and its relation to military operations”, 1820–1823].
PSZ, vol. XXIX, pp. 974-978.
Veshchikov P. I. Voyennoye khozyaystvo Russkoy armii v Otechestvennoy voyne 1812 goda [The military economy of the Russian army in the Patriotic War of 1812]. Prostranstvo i vremya. 2012. № 3 (9). S. 20 – 31.
Uchrezhdeniye dlya upravleniya Bol'shoy deystvuyushchey armii [O glavnokomanduyushchem, korpusnykh i divizionnykh nachal'nikakh i ikh shtabakh] [Establishment for the management of the Large active army [On the commander-in-chief, corps and divisional chiefs and their headquarters]] CH.1 1812. S.: Senatskaya tipografiya. Available from : https://kp.rusneb.ru/item/material/5fcf8bca991f3b9142344890 (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Kabanova A. K. Opolcheniye 1812 g. [Militia of 1812] // Otechestvennaya voyna i Russkoye obshchestvo: v 7 t. T. V. M., 1912. S. 44.
TSGIA SSSR, f. 1152, d. 219, ll. 25, 68, 92, 107. Rospisi o gosudarstvennykh dokhodakh i raskhodakh za 1807 – 1811 [Lists of state revenues and expenditures for 1807 - 1811].
Nikol'skiy P. S. Finansovaya sostavlyayushchaya voyny Rossii protiv napoleonovskogo nashestviya v 1812–1815 gody [The financial component of Russia's war against the Napoleonic invasion in 1812–1815]. Gumanitarnyye nauki. 2012. № 3 (7). S. 76 – 83.
Makarova T. K. Iz istorii denezhnogo obrashcheniya Rossii v period napoleonovskogo vtorzheniya [From the history of monetary circulation in Russia during the Napoleonic invasion]. Pravoporyadok: istoriya, teoriya, praktika. 2013. № 1(1). S. 116 – 123.
Bliokh Í. S. Finansy Rossii XIX stoletiya [Finances of Russia of the 19th century], t. Í SPb., 1882.
Gosudarstvennyye i munitsipal'nyye tsennyye bumagi [State and municipal securities]. – SPb: Piter, 2004. – 336 s.: il. ISBN 5-94723-885-3.
Solovova Ye. V. Publichnyy kredit kak institut finansovogo prava na primere Rossiyskoy Federatsii i SSHA [Public credit as an institution of financial law on the example of the Russian Federation and the USA]. avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk: 12.00.04 / MGI MO MID Rossii. Moskva, 2013.
Nikol'skiy P. S. Finansovaya sostavlyayushchaya voyny Rossii protiv napoleonovskogo nashestviya v 1812–1815 gody [The financial component of Russia's war against the Napoleonic invasion in 1812–1815]. Gumanitarnyye nauki. 2012. № 3 (7). S. 76 – 83.
Vooruzheniye russkoy armii 1812 goda [Armament of the Russian army in 1812]. Veb-sayt: War.EXE. Available from : https://warexe.ru/vooruzhenie-russkoj-armii-1812-goda/ (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Shpakovskiy V. Artilleriya dvenadtsatogo goda [Artillery of the twelfth year]. Voyennoye obozreniye. Available from : https://topwar.ru/174048-artillerija-dvenadcatogo-goda.html (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Gornyye zavody yuzhnogo Urala v otechestvennoy voyne 1812 g. i zagranichnykh pokhodakh russkoy armii [Mining factories of the southern Urals in the Patriotic War of 1812 and foreign campaigns of the Russian army]. Veb-sayt: THELIB. Available from : https://thelib.info/pedagogika/1030251-gornye-zavody-juzhnogo-urala-v-otechestvennoj-vojne-1812-g-i-zagranichnyh-pohodah-russkoj-armii/ (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Okuntsov YU. P. Pushechnoye i snaryadnoye proizvodstvo Zlatoustovskikh kazennykh zavodov 1812 – 1814 gody [Cannon and shell production of Zlatoust state-owned factories. 1812 – 1814 years]. Doklad na XX Ural'skiye Biryukovskiye chteniya, g. Chelyabinsk, 2014.
Ural v Otechestvennoy voyne 1812 goda [Ural in the Patriotic War of 1812]. Sbornik dokumentov. Sverdlovsk. S. 79 – 80.
RUGIA. F. 37. Op. 9. D. 228. L. 11.
Russkaya artilleriya v 1812 godu [Russian artillery in 1812]. Spetsproyekt pravoslavnogo zhurnala “Neskuchnyy sad”. 1 (13). URL: http://1812.nsad.ru/23 (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Pink I. B. Sbornyye ruzh'ya tul'skogo proizvodstva v period Otechestvennoy voyny 1812 goda i zagranichnykh pokhodov russkoy armii 1813–1814 gg. [Prefabricated guns of Tula production during the Patriotic War of 1812 and foreign campaigns of the Russian army in 1813–1814] Available from : https://www.borodino.ru/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/31_Pink.pdf (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Spisok s gramoty 1812-go goda, Vysochayshe pozhalovannoy tul'skomu oruzheynomu obshchestvu, na imya komandira Tul'skogo oruzheynogo zavoda, vo vremya otechestvennoy voyny [List from the charter of 1812, Highly granted to the Tula Arms Society, in the name of the commander of the Tula Arms Plant, during the Patriotic War] // Afremov I.F. Istoriya Tul'skogo kraya (Istoricheskoye obozreniye Tul'skoy gubernii). Tula, 2002. S. 193.
Branda P. Did the war pay for the war? An assessment of napoleon's attempts to make his campaigns self-financing. Napoleonica. LaRevue. 2008. № 3. P. 2 –15.
General correspondence of Napoleon published by order of Emperor Napoleon III, № 15,901.
For further discussion of these issues, see Alain Pigeard, L’Armée de Napoléon, Tallandier, 2000, p. 281-297.
Ot voyennogo khozyaystva armii i flota k tylu Vooruzhennykh sil Rossii XVIII – XX vv. [From the military economy of the army and navy to the rear of the Armed Forces of Russia in the 18th - 20th centuries] Moscow, 2011. S. 108.
Diunov M. Tyl Napoleona: kak snabzhentsy pogubili velikuyu armiyu. Veb-sayt [Rear of Napoleon: how the supply chains destroyed the great army]: warhead.su. Available from : https://warhead.su/2019/09/24/tyl-napoleona-kak-snabzhentsy-pogubili-velikuyu-armiyu (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
In the course of the campaign, the army paymasters (intendance militaire) were in charge of receiving and distributing these funds. Once the fighting was over, a settlement body (Caisse d’amortissement) had the task of managing the war monies, up until, that is, the creation of the Domaine extraordinaire in 1810.
Mikhail Arushev. Artilleriya Velikoy armii Napoleona [Artillery of Napoleon's Grand Army]. Veb-sayt: Voyennoye obozreniye. Available from : https://topwar.ru/181877-artillerija-velikoj-armii-napoleona-orudija-i-boepripasy.html. (data zvernennya 01.02.2022).
Loishyn, A. (2019). Selection of indicators of the scientific and methodological apparatus for assessing the effectiveness of the internal control system of the ministry of defense of Ukraine. Journal of Scientific Papers «Social Development and Security», 9(3), 66-90. DOI : 10.33445/sds.2019.9.3.6
Abstract views: 163 PDF Downloads: 150
Copyright (c) 2022 Anatolii Loishyn
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The authors agree with the following conditions:
1. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication (Download agreement) with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgment of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
2. Authors have the right to complete individual additional agreements for the non-exclusive spreading of the journal’s published version of the work (for example, to post work in the electronic repository of the institution or to publish it as part of a monograph), with the reference to the first publication of the work in this journal.
3. Journal’s politics allows and encourages the placement on the Internet (for example, in the repositories of institutions, personal websites, SSRN, ResearchGate, MPRA, SSOAR, etc.) manuscript of the work by the authors, before and during the process of viewing it by this journal, because it can lead to a productive research discussion and positively affect the efficiency and dynamics of citing the published work (see The Effect of Open Access).
